A man
has been found not guilty of murdering a teenager in a case that has gripped
and divided America. George Zimmerman, 29, was acquitted of second-degree
murder and manslaughter in the shooting death of 17 year old Trayvon Benjamin
Martin. A jury of six women took
more than 16 hours and 20 minutes to come to come to their unanimous decision
that the death was justifiable. Zimmerman, who was a neighbourhood watch
volunteer, was charged with second-degree murder for fatally shooting Martin on
February 26, 2012. The court was told that he had followed the unarmed
youngster through a park because he looked like he was 'up to no good.' Zimmerman,
a volunteer neighbourhood watchman, claims he shot Martin in self-defence, and
that the teen punched him repeatedly before deciding to use lethal force. The
shooting of Martin, who is African-American, by Zimmerman, who is not, has
fuelled new debates about racial profiling, gun-control, and self-defence laws.
As the
judge announced that Zimmerman had no other business with the court just after
10pm on EST on Saturday his mother, who was sat in the court, smiled for the
first time during the trial. Trayvon's parents, Tracy Martin and Sybrina Fulton, were not in court to hear the verdict.
Their reaction was said to be reserved but they expressed their disappointment.
A tweet CNN claimed came from his father said: 'I know my baby proud of fight
we along with all of you put up for him'. As the verdict drew near, police and city
leaders in the Orlando suburb of Sanford and other parts of the U.S. said they
were taking precautions against the possibility of mass protests or unrest.
'There
is no party in this case who wants to see any violence,' Seminole County
Sheriff Don Eslinger said immediately after jurors began deliberating. 'We have
an expectation upon this announcement that our community will continue to act
peacefully.' Crowds outside the courthouse were outspoken about their disappointment
at the verdict, yelling 'The system has failed us', and hundreds took to
Twitter to voice their discontentment with the justice system and jury.
Moments
after the verdict was read out, people reacting on Twitter had described
Zimmerman as 'a dead man walking'. His defence attorneys said the verdict had
not sunk in for him yet, and that Zimmerman was worried about the reaction.
Zimmerman
is said to have been in hiding and wears a bullet proof vest when outside,
according to the New
York Times. Defence attorney Mark O Mara said:
'[Zimmerman] has to be cautious and protective of his safety because there is a
fringe element who have said on Twitter and elsewhere they want revenge.'
He
added that after everyone left the room at the end of the trial, Zimmerman
thanked his defence teams and then became emotional as he realised the trial
was done. 'I'm not sure how you can feel after 16 months of trauma. It's
probably going to settle on him tonight when he is with his family and realizes
he doesn't have to come back to court,' Mr O Mara said.
Robert
Zimmerman Jr said his brother was 'going to be looking around his shoulder for
the rest of his life'. 'Now the
jury has spoken, and we are exonerated as a family,' he told CNN. 'And more importantly, George is
exonerated.' Benjamin Crump, the attorney for the Martin family, acknowledged
the disappointment of Trayvon's supporters, as he ranked the teenager
alongside civil rights heroes Medgar Evers and Emmett Till in the history of
the fight for equal justice.
But he
urged them not to resort to violence. 'For Trayvon to rest in peace, we must
all be peaceful,' he said. It took the jury five weeks to see more than 200
pieces of evidence and hear 56 witnesses in a trial that has gripped the
nation, the jury heard two very different accounts of what happened on that
fateful rainy night of February 26, 2012. They had been given the chance to
convict Zimmerman of manslaughter but did not do so, despite asking for a
clarification of the charge earlier in the evening. After the verdict,
prosecutor Bernie de la Rionda said he was disappointed but respected the
jury's decision. 'We respect the
verdict but I'm disappointed. This is only the second murder case I lost. I
thought he was guilty,' he told a press conference. Florida State Attorney
Angela Corey added that they had wanted to 'get all the facts before the jury
because we felt everyone had the right to know everything'. 'To the living we
owe respect, to the dead the truth. We believe we have brought out the truth.'
She
added: 'This case has never been about race or the right to bear arms. But
there is no doubt Trayvon was profiled to be a criminal.'
Ms Corey added after the verdict that she believed
second-degree murder was the appropriate charge because Zimmerman's mindset
'fit the bill of second-degree murder'. 'We charged what we believed we could
prove,' Ms Corey said. Ultimately, it was the defence team who won. They
praised the jury, who Mr O Mara said 'listened, took notes [and were] as
engaged as everyone in the process'. 'We are ecstatic with the results. George
Zimmerman was not guilty of anything except protecting himself in self
defence,' he added after the verdict.
He said
that they would seek immunity if someone decided to try to sue Zimmerman.
Don
West, who was criticised for his opening Knock Knock joke and photos of him on
Twitter eating ice cream with his daughters during a break early on in the
trial said he would not respond to his critics or talk about the alleged
threats made against his family. 'This trial is about George ZImmerman, not
about ice creams,' he said. 'I still think the joke was funny but I wish I'd
told it better.' Mr O Mara said: 'Nothing can bring back Trayvon Martin.
Whenever a young life is lost it is a tragedy' adding that he extended his
sympathy to the teenager's family.
He
added however: 'None of [the evidence] shows George Zimmerman as an aggressor.'
The prosecution had started the case with a powerful and graphic opening
statement and it was in this vein they proceeded with their case. Zimmerman
wasn't arrested for 44 days after the February 26, 2012, shooting as police in
Sanford insisted that Florida's Stand Your Ground law on self-defence
prohibited them from bringing charges. Florida gives people wide latitude to
use deadly force if they fear death or bodily harm.
Trayvon's
parents, along with civil rights leaders such as the Rev Jesse Jackson and Rev
Al Sharpton, argued that Zimmerman, whose father is white and whose mother is
Hispanic, had racially profiled their son. They
also accused investigators of dragging their feet because Trayvon was a black
teenager. Before a special prosecutor assigned to the case ordered Zimmerman's
arrest, thousands of protesters gathered in Sanford, Miami, New York and
elsewhere. President Obama also added to the case, saying that if he had a son,
'he'd look like Trayvon'.
The Rev
Al Sharpton continued to campaign after the verdict, saying: 'The acquittal of
George Zimmerman is a slap in the face to the American people but it is only
the first round in the pursuit of justice.' According to AP, he added: 'We
intend to ask the Department of Justice to move forward as they did in the
Rodney King case and we will closely monitor the civil case against Mr.
Zimmerman. I will convene an emergency call with preachers tonight to discuss
next steps and I intend to head to Florida in the next few days.' The first
words in the trial, from state attorney John Guy, had been: 'F***ing punks,
these a**holes always get away,' words that were repeated to the jury several
times in the three weeks of testimony. Words,
they said, that proved Zimmerman acted with ill will, spite and hatred when he
followed Trayvon as he was walking home from a 7/11 and, after a scuffle, shot
him through the heart. They portrayed Zimmerman as a 'vigilante', a 'wannabe
cop', a man filled with hatred and frustration after a spate of burglaries in
the community he felt he was responsible for protecting. On Friday, the
prosecution appealed to the emotions and the hearts of the all-women jury and
in a powerful rebuttal, John Guy said: 'Trayvon
Martin was a son, a brother and a friend and the last thing he did on this
Earth was to try to get home. 'George Zimmerman didn't shoot the teen because
he had to, he shot him because he wanted to,' repeating words he used in his
opening statement.
In
contrast, the defence took a more methodical, conversational and almost calm
approach in their delivery. Mr West included his 'Knock Knock' joke in his
opening statement, though it failed to have the desired effect.
They called only 18 witnesses to the state's 38 and
dedicated a lot of time trying to hammer home to the jury that Zimmerman feared
for his life and was merely defending himself from a vicious MMA-style beating
at the hands of Trayvon. Mr O'Mara pointed out again and again in his closing
argument the state did not prove beyond a reasonable doubt that murder in the
second-degree occurred.
'Pure
and unadulterated innocence', he said. 'In
fact, George Zimmerman committed no crime at all. 'My client is not guilty of
anything but protecting his own life,' he told the jury. Central to the case
and played numerous times by both legal teams over the last three weeks was the
911 call from a resident of the Retreat at Twin Lakes community. Terrified and
piercing screams for help can be heard in the background before a shot rings
out, silencing them instantly. The prosecution's last witness was Sybrina
Fulton, a mother who lost her only son. She took the stand and said unequivocally
the cries for help belonged to her son. On the same day, the defence called
their first witness Gladys Zimmerman, and she - just like Sybrina - told the
court it was her son George calling for help. Next up was Zimmerman's uncle,
retired sheriff Jorge Meza, who acted as a powerful witness to the defence,
revealing he was not played the 911 call but only heard it on TV and knew
instinctively who it was.
'That
voice just came and hit me. Not only did I hear the scream but I felt it. I
know it was my Georgie, I felt it,' he said while fighting back tears.
The defence also called witness after witness -
neighbours, colleagues and friends of Zimmerman - who also unwaveringly
testified that it was the neighbourhood watch volunteer shouting for help. Another
point of contention was - who attacked who at the gated community? Who was the
aggressor and who was the victim? Whose life was in danger that night? The state said Zimmerman had been
training at an MMA gym three times a week over the past year. This would match the description of
neighbour John Good, who said the person on top, the aggressor, was straddling
the person on the bottom, the victim, in a 'pound and ground' move. Rachel Jeantel, Trayvon's friend, who
was on the phone to the teen right before he was shot, told the court her
friend was frightened because a man was following him. She told him to go home. The last thing she heard Trayvon say
was: 'Why are you following me?' before the phone went dead. She also claimed
it was Zimmerman who approached Trayvon saying, 'What are you doing around
here?'
The
defence highlighted the physical differences between the 17-year-old and the
then 28-year-old. That at around 6ft, Trayvon towered over Zimmerman, who was
5ft 8in and considered to be 'soft' and borderline obese at 200lb. They said
Travyon was not a scared young boy who feared for his life, but a strapping
young man who pounced on Zimmerman and started beating him. Possibly one of the
best witnesses to take the stand in the whole trial was a forensic pathologist
who was an expert in gunshot wounds. Dr Vincent di Maio told the jury that the way the powder
marks were formed around the bullet wound showed the gun would have been
two-to-four inches away from the teenager's body when the shot was fired,
indicating he was leaning forward at the time. 'The physical evidence is
consistent with George Zimmerman's account that Mr Martin was over him,' he
said.
He
later testified that Zimmerman's head injuries could have been caused by coming
into contact with concrete, even if there were no serious injuries to show
this.
No comments:
Post a Comment